'Pakistan is the fruit of Nehru's anti-federal stance' - Jaswant Singh

Jaswant Singh - in his new book Jinnah: India - Partition, Independence blames Jawaharlal Nehru's aversion to a federal polity for the partition of the subcontinent. According to Mr. Singh, Nehru's anti-federal stance left Jinnah with no option but to press for a separate Muslim state.

BJP disowning Mr. Singh's thesis is an expected outcome because the BJP itself remains opposed to a federal polity for India even today. The BJP is full of Nehru's views of a centralized polity!

What is surprising is - all the dialogue around the book continues to look at India as a religious dichotomy or trichotomy, blissfully forgetting the fact that India is more importantly a linguistic polychotomy. With commercial interests overtaking religious ones even amongst India's elite, neglecting India's linguistic diversity is, to say the least, not a good idea.

Whether Mr. Singh is right or wrong, the fact remains that a federal polity is the best for India from the point of view of stability, integrity and development. It is high time both the Congress and BJP dropped their centralist stance and moved towards building a truly federal India where a handful states aren't licensed by the central government to "goad other states with greed for material prosperity".

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

My posts don't appear online and I am unable to contact you as your mailbox is full.

ravi turuvekere said...

Excellent, witty, quick ,, that's karnatique !

Jai Veerupaksha said...

In their own interests both the BJP and the Congress must stop feigning ignorance about more such fruits that would be borne out of such stupid anti federal stances.

Chikkodi Chinnaswamy said...

Hope both BJP & Congress self destruct with infighting in the larger interest of this nation. 2 parties hell bent on centralization to rake in the moolah.. How much more will they milk the cow?

Post a Comment

 
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...